The Benefits Of Reusing Control Logic
The first large project I worked on in my career taught me that reusing code isn???t just a way to get more done with less effort; it is also makes problems that have nothing to do with the code very obvious. Let me explain:
The project was a new 40 million gallon-per-day wastewater treatment facility in South Carolina. The commissioning of the plant went very well, and all systems checked out. A few weeks after commissioning, I was sent back to the plant because they were having a problem with their effluent pumps.
Three effluent pumps were set up in a lead-lag configuration that followed the level of the effluent wet well. When the level got high, the pumps would turn on and pump down to the low level. If one pump couldn???t keep up, a second pump started. The logic seemed to be working correctly, except the pump didn???t always stop when the level got low. The customer was very concerned that the pumps could have already been damaged by running dry.
I studied the data on the historical trends, and it appeared the problem only happened on the second pump, which the operators confirmed. The customer concluded that it must be a PLC issue and insisted we look for the solution there. My conclusion was different: I was certain that this was not a PLC issue. I was certain because I used the same logic for turning every pump on and off based on the level. If the other pumps always worked correctly, I knew there had to be something wrong outside of the PLC.
The customer was skeptical, so I started looking for a way to examine the problem and prove that the code was solid. This was a very important customer, so I had to take care of the problem quickly.
Luckily, the interposing relay used in the control cabinet had a spare set of contacts. This was a good point of demarcation for proving the PLC programming. I tied the spare set of contacts back to a spare digital input on the PLC and added that point to the history collection system. I then let the system run all day and all night.
The next day, the historical trend showed the PLC output turned off an hour before the pump finally stopped. The PLC did indeed do the right thing. The customer called in the motor controller supplier and had the contactor replaced. They never had a problem with the pump again.
I learned a valuable lesson: reusing effective code properly is not being lazy, it is good design.